Pensions & Divorce

Options for Pension Sharing After Divorce

Until the Pension Act 1995, the only method of splitting pension assets in a divorce was ‘offsetting‘. Effectively, offsetting sees non-pension assets traded off to compensate for the loss in pension assets by the one spouse.

This is the only form of pension sharing on a divorce that doesn’t need a court order, because the assets held in the pension fund(s) aren’t actually split in any way — they’re simply offset.

The method introduced by the Pension Act 1995 was known as ‘earmarking’, which involves a spouse retaining the right to a share of the pension once the member retired. Pension earmarking has since been renamed as a pension attachment order, although both terms are widely used.

While pension attachment orders have their benefits — namely providing a pension income in the former spouse’s name — it also has its disadvantages.

Arguably the main disadvantage with a pension attachment order is that the ex-spouse must wait for their former spouse to start drawing their pension to receive their share, the timing of which may not suit the ex-spouse.

The courts have no power to dictate when the spouse with the pension begins drawing an income from it, what age they should work to or even if they should continue making contributions to the scheme earmarked by the court.

The Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999 introduced a third option: a ‘clean break’ option known as pension sharing. This allowed a complete split of the pension benefits because benefits were transferred into an entirely separate pension arrangement in the ex-spouse’s name.

Offsetting Pensions in Divorce

Offsetting is the oldest method of sharing a pension in a divorce. Marital assets are traded to offset the loss in pension benefits by the other spouse. So if there is a pension fund worth £200,000 and a property also worth £200,000, the spouse with the pension would keep it intact but sign over the property to the spouse without any pension provisions to make up for the loss.

Issues With Offsetting Pensions

Pension offsetting is useful if the pension is inaccessible, such as when it’s based offshore. However, there are a number of problems with this approach. It’s difficult to make assumptions of a future benefit from a pension fund and compare those with assets such as property and cash transferred at the date of the divorce.

For the pension holder, the issue then arises that although they may have retained valuable pension rights during the split, they won’t have access to property / savings that were used to offset their pension pot. They could be left with a pension pot that they may not be able to access until retirement and not much in the way of other assets.

Offsetting is not as simple as taking the value of the pension fund at the date of separation and compensating the spouse with the equivalent in cash and property.

John Spink
Head of Financial Planning at Drewberry

Women live longer than men, for instance, so would likely be receiving a pension for longer than a former husband. This must be taken into account when determining the assets the spouse without the pension gets to compensate for the loss in pension rights.

Offsetting still could see one partner having little or no pension provisions and limited independent earning power to rectify this in time for retirement, given that the additional share of assets they receive may not easily be liquidated and put into a pension fund. This might be the matrimonial home that serves as the residence for any dependent children.

The issues with pension offsetting were a notable driver of the legislation in the Pension Act 1995 on the splitting of pensions in divorce.

Earmarking Pensions in Divorce

Under a pension attachment order, benefits are retained by the member of the pension arrangement. So if one partner’s pension was worth £10,000 per year and the other partner was entitled to 50% of this, they’d receive £5,000 of pension income.

The earmarking order can be applied separately to one or more the following:

• Pension income
• Tax-free lump sum
• Death benefits.

This option carries the following associated risks:

• The ex-spouse receives their proportion of their pension entitlement  only when the member starts taking their pension benefits, but the courts don’t have the power to stipulate when this should be
• The member is within their rights to delay drawing their pension past the scheme’s normal retirement age; there is nothing to compel them to start taking the benefits so the partner can begin receiving theirs
• The order will lapse if the ex-spouse remarries
• The order will lapse if the member dies.

People delay taking their pension for many reasons, such as not being able to afford to retire, which  may be related to the splitting of assets in the divorce if it occurred later in life, or simply not wanting to yet.

The member may not want to start drawing on their pension because, while they’re still working, taking additional income would push them into a higher tax band. Also, investments may have underperformed, and the member could be waiting for them to recover.

In addition, the member may choose to defer taking benefits because the marriage breakup was particularly unpleasant or they feel that the amount paid to their ex-spouse was excessive.

If the member has accumulated other assets after the divorce or retained them in the divorce settlement, then they may be able to comfortably retire without the pension income, leaving the ex-spouse waiting for their share.

Pension Attachment Orders and Remarriage

Although earmarking address some of the issues regarding pension sharing in divorce present in offsetting — namely it doesn’t leave one spouse without pension provisions and the other with few assets other than a pension — the approach is clearly not without issues of its own.

Pension attachment orders make no provisions for the circumstances of both parties changing over time.

Pension attachment orders cease on remarriage, but more than 1 in 5 of the men and women who entered into an opposite sex marriages in England and Wales in 2013 had previously been divorced.

It may also not be practical or desirable for the former spouses to remain in contact with each other, making a ‘clean break’ approach is the most preferable and practical solution in most cases. A clean break may be the only sensible solution if, for example, one party wishes to start a new life abroad.

Divorce Pension Sharing Order

A pension sharing order offers more of a clean break solution than is offered by a pension attachment order, and also addresses many of the other issues related to the previously discussed methods of splitting a pension after a divorce.

In these circumstances, the court will issue a pension sharing order which sets out how much of your pension scheme(s) your ex-partner is entitled to receive. This figure is a proportion of the transfer value of the scheme or schemes to be divided. The court may also rule on the proportion of the final benefit from the scheme your partner is entitled to.

Awarding Pension Credits

The pension awarded to the former partner will be in the form of a pension credit, which can then be transferred into an existing pension scheme or a new one set up to receive the transfer.

In most cases, the only option on the table will be what is known as an external transfer, with the transfer value payable to a scheme nominated by the ex-spouse outside of the member’s own plan.

Shadow Membership

The other option is less common and applies to some defined benefit schemes. Known as shadow membership, it involves the ex-spouse receiving a ‘pension credit’ based on the member’s entitlement.

So if an ex-wife was entitled to a pension of £10,000 per year and the court orders 50% of this to be transferred to her former husband, then the ex-wife’s benefit from the scheme is reduced from £10,000 to £5,000 and the ex-husband receives a ‘credit’ in his name from the scheme of £5,000 per year.

Multiple Pension Pots and Divorce

The ‘job for life’ mentality has long passed and people now change jobs an average of 9 times during their career (LV= 2017). This means that a couple could have accumulated significant wealth over a number of pension arrangements, an issue that will become more prominent over the next few years as auto-enrolment includes most people in some form of pension scheme.

Although a pension sharing order is fairly simple if there’s only one personal pension arrangement, most couples will have a number of arrangements between them, some of which may be defined benefit schemes. Having numerous pension arrangements creates complexity to the decision process because:

• Each scheme may have different rules on how the pension credit is implemented
• Each scheme will have their own fee structure for implementing the pension sharing order
• For defined benefit schemes, the transfer value may not truly reflect the benefit given up and therefore an alternative valuation may need to be calculated using a pensions expert and an actuary, which could be costly to do for several schemes
• The court must decide which schemes the pension sharing order should apply to
• One or both halves of the couple may already be receiving their pension benefits.

Valuing Pensions for a Divorce Settlement

It’s easy to value most matrimonial assets other during a divorce. The family home, cash savings and cars are all simple to put a price on. However, pensions are harder to value. Although a pension provider can offer you the transfer value of an existing arrangement, this value may not be representative of the perceived value of the benefits accrued by both parties.

To return to the earlier example in the offsetting section, is a £200,000 property worth the same as a £200,000 pension arrangement? This is dependent on a number of factors.

How easily can the house be sold at the valuation provided, and what are the selling costs? Is it possible to realise the value in the house straight away? Perhaps one half of the couple will continue living there with any children and can’t sell it immediately; will house prices have fallen in the future when they are in a position to sell?

How Do You Value a Pension in Divorce?

When valuing a pension during a divorce, you need to take into account each party’s age. Are they over 55 and thus able to access the pension arrangement with a 25% tax-free lump sum under the new pension freedoms, or are they younger and is pension planning therefore less important?

What will the income tax liability be on the income element of the pension, and how much can be taken as a cash-free lump sum? Is the CETV for a defined benefit pension a realistic value of the benefit being given up?

What if one half of the couple wants cash to hand? Funds held in a pension arrangement can’t be easily liquidated for non-pension purposes, such as if one of the former spouses wants to put down a deposit for a new house.

All these questions make it clear why valuing a pension is a difficult business and requires the input of experts. They will be able to take all of these factors into account when valuing your pension in a divorce. The end benefit is often a higher consideration than the value of the fund at the time of the divorce.

Divorce and Pensions: Statistics and Facts

• According to the Office for National Statistics, the number of people getting divorced in England and Wales has fallen from an all-time high of 165,018 in 1993 to 101,669 by 2017.
• This is likely because the number of people getting married is also fallen; each of the years 2006-2009 saw the lowest number of opposite sex marriages in England and Wales since 1895.
• Yet the divorce rate isn’t falling for those aged 60+. 9,831 men and 6,227 women aged 60 and over got divorced in 2017. For women the number has almost doubled since 1997.
• Being divorced is increasingly common – 3.7 million people in England and Wales were divorced in 2017, up from 3.4 million in 2007.
• Cohabitation has become far more common as an alternative to marriage – and cohabitation offers none of the same rights to partners’ pensions in the event of a breakup. 4.7 million people in England and Wales were cohabiting having never been married or in a civil partnership in 2017, up from 3.6 million in 2007.
• A further 1.2 million people who had previously been married or in a civil partnership were cohabiting in 2016.

Getting Advice on Pensions in Divorce

If you are currently in the process of getting divorced and would like to discuss your specific situation with one of our specialist pension advisers then please email us at wealth@drewberry.co.uk or call us on 0208 432 7333.

Alternatively, if you are a solicitor looking for pension analysis on behalf of your client we are able to assist.

How Much Does Sharing a Pension Cost?

The associated fees payable to cover the cost of the analysis work and implementing the pension sharing order are:

• Solicitor fees
• Adviser fees (and actuarial fees) for the pension calculation work
• Scheme fees to implement the sharing order
• Many pension schemes charge a fee to implement a pension sharing order and to administer it if both partners remain invested in the fund
• Public sector defined benefit schemes will likely charge for the CETV figures, and the costs can be quite high.

Your Financial Plan: Build A Better Future

A good financial plan can help you make the right decisions when it comes to your finances. Make the right decisions today to build a more prosperous future.

Good financial planning with clear goals can increase your retirement income by as much as 53%. Old Mutual Redefining Retirement Survey

Why Speak to Us…

We started Drewberry because we were tired of being treated like a number and not getting the service we all deserve when it comes to things as important as planning our finances. Below are just a few reasons why it makes sense to let us help.

• See your financial future
  We use sophisticated financial modelling technology to visually show you your financial future. A living financial plan where you can clearly see what you can achieve depending on the decisions you make – read more
• Achieve the retirement you deserve
  Can afford that dream round-the-world trip? Can you help your children onto the property ladder? We’ll model your goals and build your financial plan to help you achieve them.
• Our expertise saves you time and provides peace of mind
  Organising your pensions, investing your assets, managing risk and making the most of your tax allowances is all taken care of as part of your financial plan.
• We’ve got bargaining power on our side
  This allows us to negotiate better rates for you than dealing with providers yourself.
• You’ll speak to a dedicated expert from start to finish
  You will speak to a named expert with a direct telephone and email. No more automated machines and no more being sent from pillar to post – you’ll have someone to speak to who knows you.
• Benefit from our 5-star service
  We pride ourselves on providing a 5-star service, as can be seen from our 2386 and growing independent client reviews rating us at 4.92 / 5.
• Gain the protection of regulated advice
  You are protected. Where we provide a regulated advice service we are responsible for the decisions we help you make. Doing it yourself or going direct to a provider won’t provide this protection, so you won’t benefit from these securities.